Home / Health / Some fear the CDC will move too quickly with the new COVID mask recommendations.

Some fear the CDC will move too quickly with the new COVID mask recommendations.



Some health experts are questioning whether federal officials are moving too quickly to recommend a relaxation mask that will help people who have been vaccinated against COVID-19 to get rid of the cover of their face on site. Most indoors and outdoors And they’re advising California and local leaders to be more vigilant in loosening the mask order.

Dr. John Swartzberg, clinical professor of infectious diseases at the UC Berkeley School of Public Health, said: “There is good science to support our policy change. On the other hand, I am amazed that they are coming out very soon. I would love to have a month more under my belt to see the numbers continue to drop. ”

If California starts allowing people who are fully vaccinated in stores, who will determine if those without masks are actually vaccinated? Will the supermarket be interested in checking the vaccine card at the entrance?

“I didn̵

7;t see the grocery store confirming that you had the vaccine. It won’t happen, ”Swartzberg said.

The United Food and Commercial Workers union, which represents more than 1.3 million essential food and retail workers, has raised questions about the CDC’s move.

“As we all share our desire to return to a normalcy without a mask. But current CDC recommendations are confused and do not consider how it affects essential workers, who regularly face unvaccinated individuals and refuse to wear masks, ”said Marc Perrone, president of the International Union. The union nation said in a statement, “Key workers are still being forced to play masked police for shoppers… Should they now become vaccinated police?”

However, grocery stores can choose to maintain a no-mask and no-serve policy.

Dr. Kirsten Bibbbins-Domingo, president of UC San Francisco’s Division of Epidemiology and Biostatistics, tweeted that the science used in the CDC’s recommendations sounded good, “but who is it?” Who is responsible for implementing the policy? ”

She said some people are less likely to get vaccinated in America, a group of workers who are very busy working or caring for their families to get vaccinated. “Have we failed to do that important job again?” She asked.

Some fear the CDC’s movement will reverse and end up not wearing a mask without vaccination. That could end up harming anyone who is likely to have not been vaccinated, such as low-income residents and some blacks and Latinos, want to be vaccinated. But they cannot do it due to factors such as the feeling that they may Missed work due to vaccine side effects or unable to get vaccines from a trusted location – reasons mentioned in a recent Kaiser Family Foundation survey.

Other experts think the CDC has made a good call and thinks the new advice will appeal to people to get vaccinated as long as they can see the benefits of vaccination.

“I know a lot of people on Twitter say that those who are not vaccinated will simply say they are vaxed, some want, but many don’t. Seek it, ”tweeted Dr. Scott Scott Lee, former commissioner of the US Food and Drug Administration.

Last Friday, Dr. Rochelle Walensky, director of the U.S. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, acknowledged that more details were needed on the need for a functional indoor face mask in a specific environment that was unclear who had received it. Who is vaccinated and who is not vaccinated?

“This is the first step in guiding us. And what we need to do now is look at each of our recommendations for each of these locations, in school or daycare centers, or workplaces: Is this the right thing to do? ”Walensky said on the list. ABC’s “Good Morning America”

In addition, in practice, Walensky said it would make sense that states and counties issue orders that differ from national guidelines.

“Many decisions have to be made at the jurisdiction level,” Valensky said.

Swartzberg has criticized government officials for opening up the new economy twice too early last year, which followed a sharp rise. The question is whether lifting the mask too quickly will cause California to “burn for the third time”. It may not be possible. But it can’t be ruled out, he said.

Swartzberg said he liked the view made earlier this week by Gov. Gavin Newsom, who offered two different ideas on how to mitigate mask demand in California. His second thought, discussed on Wednesday, suggested the cancellation of the outdoor mask assignment next month. But may need to use an indoor mask a little longer.

“Instead of taking the big steps I think the CDC has taken today, I think we should take small steps towards the same goal,” Swartzberg said. But I think we can go there more safely if we are more careful. ”

Dr. Monica Gandhi, an infectious disease specialist at UC San Francisco, was one of the experts who urged the CDC to move faster to leverage masking practices and was amazed how federal officials took action. How fast on thursday She welcomed the news and said science supports the new advice.

She said the masking instructions for people who were fully vaccinated would be an incentive for people who might stop the shot.

“People need incentives right now,” Gandhi said. “I think this will help people in the fence get vaccinated.”

One of the more complicated issues for local governments is that the CDC appears to be announcing without much advice as to what is to come, and as a result, state and local officials face a difficult task to resolve. Who’s tough It is responsible for determining who has been vaccinated and who can expose it.

LA County officials were blocked by the details of the CDC’s announcement and it took nine hours before the governor’s office issued a statement on the new guidelines, saying in a tweet on Thursday night that it was investigating. Exam instructions and still “Encourage everyone Californians eligible for vaccination as we hope to reopen on June 15. ”

“We still have millions of unvaccinated people who haven’t even received a single dose,” LA County Health Director Barbara Ferrer said Thursday. “And every day, the numbers may be less. But every day someone is infected “

So it’s prudent, Ferrer said it takes time to make sure there are regulations to keep people as safe as possible.

The questions staff have to answer include what it means for workplace workers who, for whatever reason, may not be able to get vaccinated, the solution, Ferrer said, should not create a risk of spreading the virus between people who have it. It was not vaccinated at a time when LA County tried to keep the number of cases low and it continued to reopen and expand capacity.

The goal is to find the rule “to give everyone the peace of mind that we don’t have to overexposure to unnecessary,” Ferrer said. She added that, at least in the foreseeable future, “it may be impossible to remove all restrictions everywhere. ”

In CNN, Dr. Lee Na Wen, a former Baltimore health commissioner, worries that the CDC’s move allows people who have never wanted to get vaccinated or wear a face mask to enter the salon without having to cover their face, which adds to their concerns. Take risks to those who can’t be Getting vaccinated, such as a child who is too young to be vaccinated or someone with immunosuppression who is not fully protected from the vaccine

“Right now, we’re putting them at risk, and I think that will take us further from reaching herd immunity,” Wen said.

Here is the basics of CDC masking instructions:

  • Anyone who is fully vaccinated can participate in indoor and outdoor activities, big or small, without masking or spacing.
  • Non-vaccinated or partially vaccinated will still be asked to wear a mask in most indoor and most outdoor settings when interacting with people from outside the home where they may be. Not vaccinated (A single household member of the unvaccinated person can remain in the home without a mask if everyone is vaccinated.)
  • The mask remains a must for anyone traveling on public transport, including buses and trains, and in airports and stations.
  • The rule also applies to hospitals, prisons, homeless shelters and other institutional facilities.
  • Local and state rules may be stricter and will remain in effect.
  • People who are not vaccinated should wear a mask and get vaccinated immediately.




Source link